by Elan_Rasa » Wed 12 Jul 2006, 17:40:41
Observation: We tend to waste oil and don't use it responsibly (especially the US).
This point can be argued, but when you consider that about 3% of the world's pop is using 25% of the world's oil, I consider most of it's use as wasteful. Consider that most of the oil goes towards transportation purposes and maintaining an infrastructure (suburbia) that is a waste of most of our resources.
Bear with me for a moment. Suppose that you agree with the first point. Why do we waste so much? Are we, as a nation, inherently wasteful? Why do we consume so much and end up throwing so much away? Why did we build an infrastructure (extensive highway system with suburban sprawl) that is not sustainable?
Before giving my opinion, let me share a little about my background that guides my views on this. I was born in a "third world country" and lived a simple life (my family were mostly farmers -- really small scale, enough to live). While living there, nothing was wasted (even chicken feet were made into soup). Then I moved to the US when I was a child (and I consider myself fortunate to have done that). Though we didn't have much, relatively speaking from my past experience we had a lot (food, clothing, etc) and tended to waste more (buy more food than needed, clothes, etc). Later I became a poor college student (full time student and worked 30hrs per week to pay for tuition, supplies) and I tended to be very careful with my money and was very frugal... cheap, some would say. Once I started working I still saved alot and it wasn't until later that I noticed that I would also waste a lot of my money on silly stuff.
This brings me back to my original question. Why do we waste so much oil? To put it simply, we do it because we can. We built a suburbian nightmare b/c we had the means. We had tons of fuel inefficient cars b/c we had plenty of cheap oil. If each person tends to waste more as they accumulate more resources, then collectively as a nation we will waste more of everything (come on, bottled water!)
There are two problems with this argument. One is that it is based on my personal experience. Second, not everyone is the same (there are some rich individuals who are very frugal). However, as a whole, a society that has more will waste more. If so, then this wasteful behavior that has put us in such trouble, has occurred in other societies in the past and could have occurred anywhere today (misuse of oil).
Thoughts? Have you observed similar things?