GoIllini wrote:a devaluation of U.S. currency will solve our problems with consumer and federal debt.
Of course, buying energy from other countries with worthless green paper will be a huge problem that will quickly replace all the "solved problem" with even more debt. But hey, that's long term, so why worry, right?
GoIllini wrote:every respected economist out there; will tell you that in any stock, commodity, option, bond, or anything else that's traded broadly, it doesn't matter how the stuff gets traded; it matters what currency winds up in the oil exporting nations hands at the end of the day.
GoIllini wrote: it doesn't matter how the stuff gets traded; it matters what currency winds up in the oil exporting nations hands at the end of the day.
Your analysis ignores half the equation. Yes, it is nice for us if the Saudis hold dollars from all their sales. However, if Pakistan starts paying in euros instead of dollars, then guess what they keep in their bank account? What would happen to the dollar if every american switched to euros in their bank account? Sure, the corporations we buy from would convert back to dollars, but our savings would all be in euros...
Ok, that's a bad example because U.S. consumers HAVE NO SAVINGS. But guess what? Oil buying countries do. So, what happens if 100 or so countries convert all their reserves to Euros? Yeah, it would suck. Don't kid yourself -- it will make you look like a "respected economist".
I had to go ahead and point that out because seeing a person with egg on their face can be fun, but when the person was just being a completely arrogant asshole, then it is even more fun.