kublikhan wrote:There are plenty of serious posters who are knowledgable in their field who post here or that used to post at the oildrum.
I realize that. I'm not referring to them. I am commenting on a doomsday theory thread which started off with remarks like this:
...the economy is going to collapse, food shortages are a decade or two away, and there will be a die-off of the human population all because of peak oil.
That's what I was responding to. I was referring to the many doomsday adherents on this website and various other websites.
kublikhan wrote:Tom, this is a social media site. Not a scientific journal. You need to tailor your expectations and message to suit your audience... Anyone can post anything they want here. Crackpot theories...
The problem is, the doomsday theorists repeatedly claim that this stuff is all utterly scientific and akin to the laws of thermodynamics. That has been repeated thousands of times, here and elsewhere. If I go to John Michael Greer's website right now, I find repeated comparisons of this doomsday stuff not only to the laws of thermodynamics, but also to the law of
gravity.
If these guys are going to make claims like that, then it's fair for me to post basic criticisms of it. They are the ones making claims here. If they really want to be scientific then they need to answer basic objections.
The claims that this stuff is scientific, are misleading and untrue. There is no similarity between these doomsday theories and actual science. As a result, the doomsday authors are misleading people with their claims of science. I realize they're not doing it intentionally, because they too think this stuff is science, but they are still misleading people.
The problem with crackpot stuff is that real experts just ignore it. They don't even bother to respond. As a result, there is no contrary information available. When someone does a web search on these doomsday theories, they'll find crackpot sources which say "thermodynamics" over and over again, but they'll find nothing to the contrary. To some people, that's very impressive. It looks very scientific to see all this talk about thermodynamics, and nothing to rebut it. Of course, it's not really scientific, but it looks that way.
There needs to be contrary information available, so people don't think these theories are actually scientific and then throw their lives away in anticipation of doomsday.
The original poster of this thread wrote the following:
..the economy is going to collapse, food shortages are a decade or two away, and there will be a die-off of the human population all because of peak oil... This is based on solid scientific evidence.
He and others deserve to know that it is
not based on solid scientific evidence. If they want to prepare for doomsday anyway, then fine, however they should do so with their eyes open.
-Tom S