diemos wrote:AdamB wrote:diemos wrote:ROCKMAN wrote:A lot of theories come from folks that don't no shit about oil and gas production.
I don't know shit about how to extract oil and gas from the ground.
But I know that it was all created more than 100 million years ago and is finite.
Not all of it is that old. Most oil in California came from the Monterey, and it isn't more than 20 million years old, give or take.
'kay. Still not happening fast enough to keep up with what we're extracting.
Quite true. No one appears to be arguing that current generation rates are enough to begin filling up fields all over the place, and in many cases this is probably impossible without some tectonic activity happening in minutes that otherwise took millions of years.
I do recall someone making the claim back in the old peak oil days for this effect being seen somewhere in the GOM, Eugene Island block somewhere or another? If memory serves, it is a basin currently in the generation window, and doing just that. Don't know if the claim was valid or not, but based on some rooting around I couldn't immediately discredit it. Or validate it. I am aware of a documented claim of a Soviet gas field refilling itself up, but that wasn't from current thermogenic generation, but hydrates.
Just a bunch of details though, oil fields aren't filling up in any way that matters. Field level reserve growth, as it has been for decades now, matters more than most anything else except tight formation development, and that is mostly happening in the US.