gw wrote:The Bush administration and it's brainwashed minions are making it more clear than ever what a bunch of liars and hypocrites they are.Plantagenet wrote:Russia lied about not going beyond the borders of South Ossetia, and they lied when they committed to retreat in the cease-fire treaty. Their criminal invasion of Georgia and continued occupation of Georgia and ethnic cleansing of Georgians and continued attacks and murders of Georgian civilians makes them liable to war crimes prosecutions.
Plantagenet wrote:This topic is about the Russian invasion and occupation of Georgia. Every day that goes by without a Russian withdrawal by the brainwashed minions of [s]Stalin[/s] [s]Putin[/s] Medvedev makes it more clear what a bunch of liars and hypocrites they are.gw wrote:The Bush administration and it's brainwashed minions are making it more clear than ever what a bunch of liars and hypocrites they are.Plantagenet wrote:Russia lied about not going beyond the borders of South Ossetia, and they lied when they committed to retreat in the cease-fire treaty. Their criminal invasion of Georgia and continued occupation of Georgia and ethnic cleansing of Georgians and continued attacks and murders of Georgian civilians makes them liable to war crimes prosecutions.
Micki wrote:Please, Stalin was a Georgian.Plantagenet wrote:This topic is about the Russian invasion and occupation of Georgia. Every day that goes by without a Russian withdrawal by the brainwashed minions of [s]Stalin[/s] [s]Putin[/s] Medvedev makes it more clear what a bunch of liars and hypocrites they are.gw wrote:The Bush administration and it's brainwashed minions are making it more clear than ever what a bunch of liars and hypocrites they are.
Plantagenet wrote:Of course he was. That doesn't change the fact that he committed mass murder in Georgia and throughout the Soviet Union, nor that there are still brainwashed Stalinists in Russia.Micki wrote:Please, Stalin was a Georgian.
Micki wrote:You mean more crazy Georgians in Russia? Horrible thought.
idiom wrote:What problem?
Plantagenet wrote:idiom wrote:What problem?
The Russian invasion and occupation of about 1/3 of their neighboring country, Georgia. It happened a couple of weeks ago----its been in all the new reports.
eastbay wrote:Plantagenet wrote:idiom wrote:What problem?
The Russian invasion and occupation of about 1/3 of their neighboring country, Georgia. It happened a couple of weeks ago----its been in all the new reports.
Maybe people aren't thinking much of anything about this minor Russian humanitarian police action with their tiny errant neighbor because it's really next to nothing compared to the trillion dollar multiple 100% military occupations the USA is currently engaged in. None of which is even in the same hemisphere as the US!
Plantagenet wrote:True enough. But its still very important to the Georgians, and its worrying to the Poles, people in the Baltic states etc., and its of concern to Europeans and other people living in the EU and adjacent countries in the eastern hemisphere, and it is even a matter of interest to at least a few Americans, Canadians etc.eastbay wrote:Maybe people aren't thinking much of anything about this minor Russian humanitarian police action with their tiny errant neighbor because it's really next to nothing compared to the trillion dollar multiple 100% military occupations the USA is currently engaged in. None of which is even in the same hemisphere as the US!
NewsJournalOnline wrote:As a political science professor and director of Russian Studies at Stetson University, Eugene Huskey regularly visits Central Asia. He is one of the West's foremost experts on the politics of Kyrgyzstan, which borders China, the larger nation of Kazakhstan, and other former Soviet states south of Russia's border. Earlier this month in the airport at Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan's capital, he noticed that flights west to Tiblisi, Georgia, across the Caspian Sea, were canceled. Something was up.
The Georgian military began shelling the breakaway republic South Ossetia, where many residents identified more closely with neighboring Russia than their home country. Russian troops then invaded Georgia, a democratic country the United States had given $75 million in aid in 2007. During the fight, Russian troops exerted muscle but western leaders including President Bush decried the Russian actions, while French President Nicolas Sarkozy negotiated a cease-fire.
Q. How much of this conflict is Russia's fault?
That's a tough one. I think structurally Russia wanted to do what it did. It has been waiting for the right moment over the last several years. This is a frozen conflict, a conflict frozen in place since very shortly after the breakup of the Soviet Union. South Ossetians didn't want to be governed by the Georgians and looked to Russia as their protectors. Russia was very keen to play that role, and had so-called peacekeeping troops moving gradually into the area.
The western NATO decision to support independence for Kosovo (in 1999) was seen by Russia as crossing a line. Their allies were the Serbs. They thought it was inexcusable that Kosovo should be separated from Serbia. So they thought: Why shouldn't it happen in South Ossetia, and we're going to play the role that NATO had done in supporting Kosovo. They were also offended in 2003 (during the ascension to power by Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili), the movement of Georgia toward NATO and Georgia's involvement in the Iraq war. They thought: Here's a small country on our border that is destined to become part of NATO and we can't allow that to happen. Russia drew a line in the sand. They just don't like Saakashvili. He is temperamental and disrespectful.
Q. How much of this conflict is Georgia's fault?
I think the immediate conflict you can lay at Georgia's feet. The way they were shelling the capital, Tskhinvali, I found it difficult to understand what Saakashvili thought they were going to do to get out of this. He misread (Russian Prime Minister Vladimir) Putin and (President Dmitry) Medvedev. I think this is a very serious miscalculation on the part of the Georgians.
dissident wrote: Georgia cannot use the excuse that it engaged in gunfire exchanges with South Ossetians since it was brutally provoking them by launching periodic shelling of Tskhinvali and South Ossetian villages with mortar bombs.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests