Donate Bitcoin

Donate Paypal


PeakOil is You

PeakOil is You

TheOilDrum vs. Academia

General discussions of the systemic, societal and civilisational effects of depletion.

TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Apollo » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 14:20:09

An interesting take on the early success of the now defunct TheOilDrum:

In Engineering fields, such as energy, peer reviewed work is generally not too difficult to grasp, perhaps requiring some college grade mathematics or physics, but rarely highly advanced knowledge. While most engineers and economists should be able to gather the sort of knowledge published by TheOilDrum just by browsing peer reviewed literature, in practice they are barred from it due to the closed access policy prevailing in Academia.


This is very true, peer review is big business, if you can't afford it you're left in the dark.

This is where TheOilDrum really nailed it. First of all because it was by nature open access, available to all and taking full advantage of modern communication technologies. And secondly because it dealt with peer review in an elegant way: content was subject only to a mild and swift revision before publication, the real thing would happen after publication. This way the review become far more serious, instead of anonymous feedback from mere two reviewers - that may lack the knowledge to evaluate the work - an article published by TheOilDrum was available for review to the whole world, in a completely open and transparent process.


Sometimes I'm left wondering if academia really functions to the benefit of the masses...

Perhaps this was also the key to the success of other sites like EnergyBulletin or PO.com.
Apollo
Wood
Wood
 
Posts: 18
Joined: Thu 10 Apr 2014, 14:30:31

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Paulo1 » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 14:59:00

I am still hoping that TOD returns after this break. While they drifted in scope and message towards the end, contributions by readers, expert opinions, and links were excellent.

Paulo
Paulo1
Coal
Coal
 
Posts: 425
Joined: Sun 07 Apr 2013, 15:50:35
Location: East Coast Vancouver Island

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Pops » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 15:05:02

The message that dominated the final years of the website, inducing that nothing practical can be made about Peak Oil or other energy constraints, is self defeating. If nothing can be done, then why bother?


PO.com went through a similar period when folks who were especially partial to the [smilie=new_popcornsmiley.gif] grew tired of all the cornicopians posting hopeful stuff and left to gather elsewhere and point out the "dots" of impending collapse to each other.

We have a new crop of popcornies rhapsodising on imminent climate catastrophe - second verse - same as the first!

I liked TOD but except for Gail it was mostly about rocks and though they are sorta interesting, there are just a heck of a lot of other angles to the story.
The legitimate object of government, is to do for a community of people, whatever they need to have done, but can not do, at all, or can not, so well do, for themselves -- in their separate, and individual capacities.
-- Abraham Lincoln, Fragment on Government (July 1, 1854)
User avatar
Pops
Elite
Elite
 
Posts: 19746
Joined: Sat 03 Apr 2004, 04:00:00
Location: QuikSac for a 6-Pac

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby ROCKMAN » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 16:19:21

Pops – “…was mostly about rocks and though they are sorta interesting, there are just a heck of a lot of other angles to the story.” So true IMHO. They hold very little of my interest in this PO saga. And I’m a geologist. LOL.

But the rocks themselves haven’t held much interest for me even in the oil patch. I’ve always focused more on the processes: the deposition of rocks, their chemical alterations, structural deformation, etc. Even today I have only one in my collection: a very nice piece of pyrite. And I keep it around just to remind me to never again do really stupid/dangerous things for shiny baubles like I did when I almost killed myself collecting that pyrite in a Mexican copper mine many decades ago. LOL.
User avatar
ROCKMAN
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 11397
Joined: Tue 27 May 2008, 03:00:00
Location: TEXAS

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Plantagenet » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 16:34:04

wrote:While most engineers and economists should be able to gather the sort of knowledge published by TheOilDrum just by browsing peer reviewed literature, in practice they are barred from it due to the closed access policy prevailing in Academia.


There is no "closed access" policy in Academia.

The problem with the Oil Drum had nothing to do with Academia or some imagined competition or dispute between the Oil Drum and Academia.

The people running the Oil Drum got burned out and quit and shut down their site---Academia had nothing to do with it.

Image
The people running the Oil Drum got burned out and quit.
User avatar
Plantagenet
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 26616
Joined: Mon 09 Apr 2007, 03:00:00
Location: Alaska (its much bigger than Texas).

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Apollo » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 18:31:53

Plantagenet wrote:There is no "closed access" policy in Academia.


On which planet?

Plantagenet wrote:The problem with the Oil Drum had nothing to do with Academia or some imagined competition or dispute between the Oil Drum and Academia.


Totally agree. I'm just wondering why did you wrote this, the point was totally diverse.

Plantagenet wrote:The people running the Oil Drum got burned out and quit and shut down their site


The amount of ex-contributors presently running their own blogs tells otherwise.
Apollo
Wood
Wood
 
Posts: 18
Joined: Thu 10 Apr 2014, 14:30:31

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby step back » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 19:20:53

There are different levels of credentials and pomposity.

The Oil Drum (TOD) had fairly good credentials but no pomposity.

Academia is big on pomposity.

Image
step back
Wood
Wood
 
Posts: 4
Joined: Fri 28 Feb 2014, 19:44:22

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby rockdoc123 » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 23:29:11

Here are some facts for you.
The information if you want to seek it out is all available any time you want (at least during opening hours) at most universities in large cities. This is especially true for the technical universities such as A&M, Brown, School of Mines etc. It is called a "library". I know that for you under the age of 40 you have probably never heard of this concept but it is where all of these journals that you see on the Internet behind paywalls are archived and available to read free of charge. Yes it is a strange concept...one that flies in the face of your understanding of internet commerce but they are stored there much as they were a number of decades ago when I was doing grad work. If you wanted to understand a subject you went and grabbed all those recent journals off the shelves (Journal of Geophysical Research, Geologisch Rundschau, Geology, AAPG Bulletin, Journal of Tectonophysics, Geology, GSA Bulleting and literally hundreds more) found a paper on the subject and then began to backtrack the various references to work your way to the source of the original idea.

So rather than academia keeping you from understanding what is going on it is your own preconceived notions (and possibly the fact you would just like to click on a mouse than get on a bus) that are keeping you from that learning.

The Oildrum provided a service but I have to tell you if you thought everything you read there was based on a lot of research and good basic knowledge in the subject you are mistaken. Some of the posts were very good, some were absolute full of BS but certainly liked to portray to everyone that they had solved some great puzzle.

The general public is easily lead astray by articles that seem to be scientifically based.....hey he/she must be brilliant because they are saying all these things in a way I can understand. A case in point was Twighlight in the Desert where the author purported to have read several hundred articles on Saudi Arabia from the SPE. A few years ago I showed how it was pretty apparent he had read the abstracts to those papers (readily available free of charge on the internet through ONEPETRO) but had not read the actual papers which told a completely different story than he was putting forth.

In any event if you want to learn about Petroleum engineering, geology, extraction etc......go to your library. Oil and Gas Journal, Oilweek are both great sources for small articles that describe all sorts of interesting things. Oh and if you go to their website you will be disappointed because it cost money to subscribe....but guess what your local university library almost certainly subscribes and you can read it free there.

sometimes the old ways are better
User avatar
rockdoc123
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 7685
Joined: Mon 16 May 2005, 03:00:00

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Plantagenet » Wed 23 Apr 2014, 23:50:05

Apollo wrote:
Plantagenet wrote:There is no "closed access" policy in Academia.

On which planet?


On this planet, in the US. Which planet do you imagine has a closed access policy in academia?

Apollo wrote:
Plantagenet wrote:The problem with the Oil Drum had nothing to do with Academia or some imagined competition or dispute between the Oil Drum and Academia.

Totally agree. I'm just wondering why did you wrote this, the point was totally diverse.


Have you forgotten the title you put on this thread i.e. "TheOilDrum vs. Academia" The title doesn't make any sense, as there was no competition or dispute between the Oil Drum and Academia. Get it now?

Apollo wrote:
Plantagenet wrote:The people running the Oil Drum got burned out and quit and shut down their site
The amount of ex-contributors presently running their own blogs tells otherwise.


It doesn't matter how many ex-contributors are presently running their own blogs. The fact remains that the Oil Drum site is closed down, and the reason it is closed is that the people who ran the Oil Drum got burned out and quit and shut down their site.

Image
Its too bad the people who ran the Oil Drum got burned out and quit and shut down their site
User avatar
Plantagenet
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 26616
Joined: Mon 09 Apr 2007, 03:00:00
Location: Alaska (its much bigger than Texas).

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby ROCKMAN » Thu 24 Apr 2014, 08:50:34

P - Along those same lines: I've repeatedly asked those who have offered the "reason" why TOD shut down to explain the popularity of peakoil.com and why it hasn't shutdown for the same "reason" TOD did. I still haven't seen one response. The truly silly aspect of their position is that they are posting it on a peak oil website. LOL.
User avatar
ROCKMAN
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 11397
Joined: Tue 27 May 2008, 03:00:00
Location: TEXAS

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Paulo1 » Thu 24 Apr 2014, 09:41:21

RocDoc,

I have done extensive research over the years....while attending university for one reason or another. I loved it, to be honest.

When you live 250 miles away from the bricks/mortar site that is no longer possible.

When you are no longer in a formal program the online journals are not easily accesible. The subscription costs for access are not worth it, imo. The ERIC system I last used was irritating.

TOD and PO provide this access and info from folks like WestTexas, yourself, Rockman, Ron P, and others with industry experience who can go to the heart of the issues. Academic research is not too appealing for those with 'cats to kill and contracts to fill.' Internet forum sites allow me to get up at 5:00 am and do some reading before the house wakes and we have to get on with life. It also allows me to quickly check posts at lunch or while supper cooks. It is also entertaining. It has been interesting to observe common themes despite different levels of doom and gloom. The data and visuals are somethings I always return to and I often post reprints and/or links to others in my life.

Paulo
Paulo1
Coal
Coal
 
Posts: 425
Joined: Sun 07 Apr 2013, 15:50:35
Location: East Coast Vancouver Island

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Pops » Thu 24 Apr 2014, 10:15:27

ROCK, imho TOD tried too hard to be "official" (editors, boards, legal framework, etc) in order to affix authority to what were/are basically guesses about the future.

I'm not arguing they didn't get tired and burned out or that their content was irrelevant or that they didn't make a huge contribution to the conversation; just that educated guesses are still guesses and once you attempt to affix some kind of authority to your guess, your authority lives and dies with that guess.

To be honest, I think PO.com always had some "Authority Envy" in regard to TOD, but otoh, as "the Wild West" (as we were termed by some TODllers) the fact is we are an open forum and so antiauthoritarian by nature - and I gotta tell ya, that has hacked off more than one volunteer who couldn't handle the heat in the kitchen! LOL

We are a place for the regular Joe to discuss the news of the day, make wild ass guesses and hurl ad homs, so we really don't have any credibility to lose, LOL. OTOH, since we claim no authority and have no official stance; whatever WAG that is tossed out is just more food for thought.

Folks want gurus, someone to digest the news for them and bring down the Word from on high, so no doubt blogs will come and go but I hope PO.com stays around to digest The Word. A big hat tip to doc & yourself & Ron P & westexas and others that keep us at least somewhat squared away on the minutia of the biz.
The legitimate object of government, is to do for a community of people, whatever they need to have done, but can not do, at all, or can not, so well do, for themselves -- in their separate, and individual capacities.
-- Abraham Lincoln, Fragment on Government (July 1, 1854)
User avatar
Pops
Elite
Elite
 
Posts: 19746
Joined: Sat 03 Apr 2004, 04:00:00
Location: QuikSac for a 6-Pac

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby rockdoc123 » Thu 24 Apr 2014, 13:21:36

TOD and PO provide this access and info from folks like WestTexas, yourself, Rockman, Ron P, and others with industry experience who can go to the heart of the issues. Academic research is not too appealing for those with 'cats to kill and contracts to fill.' Internet forum sites allow me to get up at 5:00 am and do some reading before the house wakes and we have to get on with life. It also allows me to quickly check posts at lunch or while supper cooks. It is also entertaining. It has been interesting to observe common themes despite different levels of doom and gloom. The data and visuals are somethings I always return to and I often post reprints and/or links to others in my life.


fair enough, one has to set their priorities in life. But realize that you are not getting the same level of information from a blogger or a press release (invariably written by someone with an arts degree and younger than my favorite pair of brogues) that you would from the source. It isn't easy if you aren't versed in a particular topic to separate the wheat from the chaff and the chaff from the rodent turds.

When the internet was in its infancy (maybe a decade before Al Gore apparently invented it) I used to participate in a number of usenet groups where the participants were almost all scientists working in that particular field. It was a great way to exchange opinions and learn new aspects of a particular topic as long as you were handy with Unix language. And then someone invented Netscape and this type of interaction seemed to disappear.
User avatar
rockdoc123
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 7685
Joined: Mon 16 May 2005, 03:00:00

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Plantagenet » Thu 24 Apr 2014, 13:44:33

Paulo1 wrote:RocDoc,

I have done extensive research over the years....while attending university for one reason or another. I loved it, to be honest.

When you live 250 miles away from the bricks/mortar site that is no longer possible.


Good point.

I live near a University and work at the University, and I'm a big booster of the value of Universities.

I never saw things as Oildrum vs. Academia or Peak oil vs. Academia----I see it as Oid Drum AND the university, or Peak Oil AND the University.

The more intelligent and open avenues there are available for discussion and exchange of ideas the better.

Image
User avatar
Plantagenet
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 26616
Joined: Mon 09 Apr 2007, 03:00:00
Location: Alaska (its much bigger than Texas).

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Paulo1 » Fri 25 Apr 2014, 09:41:26

One other point about access to info.

The public needs to be informed. For the most part, folks in the oil industry doing more than basic production chores already 'get it'. For those folks, discourse on forums must seem pretty poor quality. However, I used to be in aviation in another life. While I bailed due to stagnating opportunities my friends did not. In fact, they are still involved in an industry that some of the major costs are fuel and finance. For those in the utility end of things (helicopters and fire fighting ....water bombers) their jobs will be somewhat secure for the next while. Airlines, the holy employment grail of my generation, not so much. You cannot believe their reaction when the data indicates they had better make other plans before retirment. Also, I believe I have been able to steer many future airline wannabes into other fields.

I have also been able to use this data and put it in layman terms, mostly because I have both a technical background and an arts background. I used PO information and sources as a contact person for university business students and at high school level. You can only imagine the looks of unbelieveable anger when parents confronted me about this. They could not believe I was not encouraging their children to attend university unless they had a specific focus that would take them forward in a low energy future. But, I had the facts. Now, a few years after retirement I remind some of my critical ex-colleagues the unsustainable levels of student loan debt, and the lack of opportunities for traditional university grads. I also point out the 6 figure wages for those students I got started in 'trades' in the oil industry. egads...the horror!!

So, the facts and discussion on PO should not be limited to academics or professionals any more than medical research should stop with the researchers or exist in the silos of research departments.

By the way, the most effective professor I ever had was an engineering dropout. He was attending university on the GI bill after a stint in the marines. One day he popped into a theatre on the way back from classes and heard TS Elliot read his poetry. He quit engineering that day and eventually finished off a double major in Literature and Philosophy. The world was a better place for his thoughts and knowledge. When I asked him why he told me he felt 'dead' before he started his Arts program.

Don't diss the arts, Roc Doc. :) We are all different.

Paulo
Paulo1
Coal
Coal
 
Posts: 425
Joined: Sun 07 Apr 2013, 15:50:35
Location: East Coast Vancouver Island

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby rockdoc123 » Fri 25 Apr 2014, 13:14:13

Don't diss the arts, Roc Doc. :) We are all different.


I heard an article on the CBC yesterday morning that had to do with some town (I think in Manitoba) where the city council had paid thousands of dollars for an "art installation" where the artist apparently piled up a bunch of straw bails and wrapped them in shrink wrap. Various citizens have taken it upon themselves to pin notes to the exhibit such as " we pay the city to remove garbage from the street not place it here". So, sometimes cow manure is just a polite word for shit.
User avatar
rockdoc123
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 7685
Joined: Mon 16 May 2005, 03:00:00

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Apollo » Thu 01 May 2014, 04:26:37

rockdoc123 wrote:The information if you want to seek it out is all available any time you want (at least during opening hours) at most universities in large cities. This is especially true for the technical universities such as A&M, Brown, School of Mines etc. It is called a "library". I know that for you under the age of 40 you have probably never heard of this concept but it is where all of these journals that you see on the Internet behind paywalls are archived and available to read free of charge.


This was true some 20 years, but not any longer. First of all for many Journals are no longer printed; some recent Journals never had a printed version. Secondly because many of the old printed editions in Libraries have been digitised (in the country where I presently work the entire national library is being digitised, in a few years they'll only be running servers).

In all the places I have studied or worked, I was never able to get into a university library without a student/researcher badge. In some cases a badge is necessary just to access the campus (private universities). Recently I have worked mostly with national libraries, whom invariably have contracts with publishers (Elsevier, Springer) solely for digital access. For budgetary reasons universities have increasingly tied up to these digital contracts set up by national libraries.

I have no idea how you tried to guess (and miss) my age, but I am pretty sure you haven't been in research/academia for a good while.
Apollo
Wood
Wood
 
Posts: 18
Joined: Thu 10 Apr 2014, 14:30:31

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby Apollo » Thu 01 May 2014, 04:31:31

It is interesting to see how this thread veered into the causes for TOD closing down; it seems most just ignored the initial post.

While it is a pity TOD closed down, the fact is that it produced an outburst of content in the many other blogs that succeeded it, and of course, here at PO :)
Apollo
Wood
Wood
 
Posts: 18
Joined: Thu 10 Apr 2014, 14:30:31

Re: TheOilDrum vs. Academia

Unread postby rockdoc123 » Thu 01 May 2014, 11:41:10

This was true some 20 years, but not any longer.


Well obviously your mileage may vary but I was at one of the universities that I attended libraries about a month and a half ago. Perhaps being an alumni who contributes regularly gives me a leg up but I am aware that particular university gets lots of money from the government and as a consequence cannot bar the public from access. My understanding is it is as simple as applying for access much like you would with a public library. Access to certain collections might be limited but likely not.

Whether the old journals have been converted to digital or not is immaterial, the information is still available in one form or another. If I wanted the second issue from the first volume of Geologic Society of America Bulletin I guaranty I could find it there. Given this is a tech oriented university with lots of oil money behind it the petroleum industry related journals are all there.

Also I am pretty sure that libraries around the world share information. Your public library should be able to request a reprint of a journal article from the local university. I haven't done that in a long while but it used to work pretty well even for the recent journals as long as you were only requesting one article and not the whole journal edition.

As well there is a tried and true method which is to request reprints from the authors. I've published a number of articles (years ago of course) and each time the authors were able to request a number of reprints of their article. The author could then distribute those to colleagues etc at his/her own discretion.
User avatar
rockdoc123
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 7685
Joined: Mon 16 May 2005, 03:00:00


Return to Peak Oil Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 70 guests