Donate Bitcoin

Donate Paypal


PeakOil is You

PeakOil is You

Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

General discussions of the systemic, societal and civilisational effects of depletion.

Do you want oil production to peak, sometime in the reasonably near future?

Yes I do
103
53%
No I don't
93
47%
 
Total votes : 196

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Oil-Finder » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 19:35:30

Well, these poll results so far confirm what I've already said several times during my brief time here: The majority of you believe in peak oil because you want oil production to peak, not because you truthfully care whether there is a lot of oil left in the ground or not.

In response to a couple of comments, the whole purpose of this poll had nothing to do with whether anyone believes oil production will peak sometime soon or not. I merely want to know what you peak oilers desire. That is the only purpose of this poll.
User avatar
Oil-Finder
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 630
Joined: Tue 11 Dec 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Seattle

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Twilight » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 19:50:39

I voted no.

But that's a formality.

Here is the interesting part. Do you think it makes a difference?
Twilight
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 3027
Joined: Fri 02 Mar 2007, 04:00:00

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Nicholai » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 19:58:30

Peak Oiler will only debate within his own threads, and will always make a structured circumstance to keep the argument within the bounds that he desires, to achieve the point that he desires.

He says that with billions of barrels left in P2 and P3 oil, we're fine. Nothing else matters, we have lots, problem solved. Sure we're not building the infrastructure needed to offset the massive depletion going on in the world's major conventional fields, but that's not a problem right?

I asked him to show me a chart of every field coming online for every field going into depletion, to prove that there will be a problem-free transition from conventional to unconventional sources. He could not deliver. (ex, for every 0.5 mbd of production lost from Cantarel, 0.1 mbd would be increased in Alberta, 0.1 in Venezuela, 0.1 in Kuwait, 0.1 in Russia, 0.1 in X)

He'll avoid the specifics of my argument once again to offer a heavily linked article with a lengthy generalized argument...just as he always does.
User avatar
Nicholai
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri 15 Jun 2007, 03:00:00
Location: St.Albert, AB

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Pretorian » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 20:15:04

Concerned wrote:I voted yes.

We have the technology and the wherewithal to change.

- We can use solar and other alternatives like wind. Microwave technology from space would be amazing.
- We can use modern safer nuclear reactor designs as well as the breeder reactors they are working on making commercially viable.
- We can work less hours like the French do and hunter gatherers of old did.
- We can recycle and build things so that they last and not simply throw away to be replaced every 5 years.
- We can share this rich sustainable life with all mankind. e.g. nano solar is now cost competitive with coal. When it scales up it will provide clean energy for all humanity.

What [s]can[/s] COULD we do collectively if we HAD stopPED breeding A VERY LONG TIME AGO and move our military budgets to cutting edge energy technology?






Here you go, fixed that forya
Pretorian
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat 08 Apr 2006, 03:00:00
Location: Somewhere there

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby whereagles » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 20:18:07

Concerned wrote:
whereagles wrote:
Lighthouse wrote:why would anyone want peakoil to happen?


maybe because then we don't wan't to trigger the methane hydride gun?


I think Japan is set to start pulling on that trigger :)

There was a story going around the other day about Japan mining the ocean for them.


I read that story the other day and can't say I was pleased. In fact, there's a professor where I work whose area of research is precisely... methane hydride extraction.

Oh, and he teaches environmental science... go figure :roll:
User avatar
whereagles
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 586
Joined: Wed 17 Aug 2005, 03:00:00
Location: Portugal

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Oil-Finder » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 20:19:17

Nicolai, before I gave you a link to The Oil Drum's own megaprojects database. If you aren't satisfied with that, there's nothing more I can do.

As I said before, the purpose of this poll is to ascertain peak oiler's desires. Is there any particular reason why every single thread must turn into a thread on everything and anything to do with peak oil? Or, is it possible to have specific threads on specific topics? I hope the latter.
User avatar
Oil-Finder
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 630
Joined: Tue 11 Dec 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Seattle

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Twilight » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 21:01:43

You still have not explained why desires matter.
Twilight
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 3027
Joined: Fri 02 Mar 2007, 04:00:00

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Oil-Finder » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 21:29:09

Twilight wrote:You still have not explained why desires matter.

Desires are important because it helps determine why some of you believe peak oil.

If someone wants oil production to peak, they will believe in peak oil and promote it regardless of how much extractable oil was left in the ground. Somebody could discover a trillion barrels of high quality light sweet crude not far beneath the sands of Algeria tomorrow, and such a person would go into denial and come up with all kinds of excuses as to why most of it will never be recovered, etc., even if such excuses weren't true.

I'm accusing such people of dishonesty. Rather than being concerned about the technical/scientific merits of "peak oil" theory itself, in truth they don't care about whether we're halfway through the world supply of extractable oil or not. The only thing they really care about is that we stop producing and consuming so much oil.

As I said in another thread, this reminds me of people who go to church even though they could care less about the religion itself. Instead, they go to church because they like the people, or they like the rituals, or perhaps the architecture of the cathedral, or some other (shallow) reason. This is dishonest. If you go to church, you should go because you actually believe the religion.

Likewise, "peak oilers" who promote peak oil not because they actually care about whether we're halfway through the world supply of recoverable oil, but because they want us to stop polluting or consuming, are being as dishonest as the person who goes to church without actually caring about the religious creed.

For those of you who voted 'no' in this poll, this criticism does not apply to you.
User avatar
Oil-Finder
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 630
Joined: Tue 11 Dec 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Seattle

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Nicholai » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 21:50:35

Why would I ever WANT to believe in peak oil? I'm 18, I live in the suburbs, I'm going to college, I have very little money to stalk up, I have a nice family and wonderful parents...why would I want to see it all come down?

I understand that the rate of depletion in the world's major fields is much faster than the rate of expansion from our unconventional sources. I also understand that China increased its energy consumption by 20% in 2005 (largest growth in one year in all of human history for an industrialized country) and supply is quickly being outpaced by demand. Demand is growing faster than any other time in history and supply is becoming harder and more expensive to find/produce. Not only that, but Saudi Arabia still isn't revealing its reserve details, meaning that the world is still unsure at what pace we must work to build up our unconventional sources to avoid any major supply shocks.

Alberta will never produce 5 mbd, if you read the Edmonton Journal everyday, you would understand that such a goal (for any long period of time) is madness.
User avatar
Nicholai
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri 15 Jun 2007, 03:00:00
Location: St.Albert, AB

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Oil-Finder » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 21:57:45

Nicholai wrote:Why would I ever WANT to believe in peak oil? . . .

That's not quite the same thing I was asking . . .

I had asked, "Do you want oil production to peak?"

You just said, "Why would I ever want to believe in peak oil?"

If you do not want oil production to peak, then you should have selected 'no' in the poll, and my criticism explained above does not apply to you.

However, a majority of people responding to this poll do want production of oil to peak.

The rest of your reply was off-topic. Sorry.
User avatar
Oil-Finder
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 630
Joined: Tue 11 Dec 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Seattle

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby thuja » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 22:26:58

Oil-finder- are you serious? We haven't had someone who doesn't belive that worldwide oil production is peaking or near peaking for a long time...

I just haven't seen your posts yet- but that's wonderful...

Do you realize that everyone- even the major oil companies, the IEA and even the conservative think tanks believe we are nearing peak within a decade or two.

Now to your question- its fairly complex-

On one hand I don't want it to occur because I know that the decline rate will lead to immense hardship, chaos and die-off...

Do I want that? No.

But I also realize that the peaking of fossil fuels will mean less CO2 emissions and therefore will lead to less Greenhouse gasses and less Global Warming. This in turn will allow us to retain the neccesary ecological vital supports to allow for continued carrying capacity for all life. So on a greater level- it is a good thing".

So due to that my answer would be yes.

So its complex- I don't want unmitigated pain and horror throughou the 21st century. But I want to make sure there will be an Earth left to inhabit in the 22nd...

Get it?
User avatar
thuja
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2202
Joined: Sat 15 Oct 2005, 03:00:00
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Oil-Finder » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 22:31:54

thuja,

As to the first half of your response, as I've already said before, this is not about whether anyone believes oil production will peak, or the technical merits thereof, this poll is about how many here want oil production to peak. So far a majority have voted yes.

As for the 2nd half of your reply, when I made the poll I actually had created a third "Other/Undecided" selection, but the stupid forum software cut that one off for some reason. :(
User avatar
Oil-Finder
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 630
Joined: Tue 11 Dec 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Seattle

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby thuja » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 22:54:48

Oil-finder I am impressed you would stick around here as you will find few to no allies- so kudos for you for sticking it out. On the other hand- I think your logic leaves something to be desired. It goes something like this-

Those who want Peak Oil (for ecological reasons/Global Warming) lasck the rationality to even acknowledge new finds or the potential for greater oil exploitation because they are so locked into their belief that they are blind, in denial and locked into a semi-religious belief system around the peaking of fossil fuels.

I would have to suggest the opposite- that anyone studying the issue with any degree of open-mindedness will soon see that it is evident that we have peaked or are very near the peaking of oil. This is not a desire led belief leading to blindness- it is self-evident and has been noted by...everybody (IEA, Oil companies, even CERA). You are completely alone. If on the other hand you ignore the reality of the situation then I would suggest that it is you in a state of semi-religious denial. Sorry...

So do some of us want the peak of oil and that colors our thinking? No we acknowledge the peaking and then see the possible advantages...
User avatar
thuja
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2202
Joined: Sat 15 Oct 2005, 03:00:00
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Narz » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 22:57:34

Oil-Finder. I want oil production to peak soon AND I believe honestly that it will. Those two aren't mutually incompatible. If it turns out my beliefs are wrong I will accept that but I still want it to happen.

Note : I don't want billions to suffer, riots, rape, mayhem, genocide. Ideally I'd like to see a powerdown/efficient technofix/re-localization movement etc.

My desires (and personal actions) matter but only on a small scale since I can't directly control other people. My beliefs are independent of my desires.
“Seek simplicity but distrust it”
User avatar
Narz
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2360
Joined: Sat 25 Nov 2006, 04:00:00
Location: the belly of the beast (New Jersey)

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby JohnDenver » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 23:06:06

Oil-Finder wrote:The only thing they really care about is that we stop producing and consuming so much oil.

That's not really true either. Sure the folks here talk a lot about how we need to do something about peak oil and carbon emissions. But mostly that's just their lips flapping. Basically, they're all a bunch of hypocrits living energy guzzling lifestyles, like Al Gore. They attack Bush&Cheney for waging a "War for Oil", and then fire up the SUV to go to a Peak Oil meeting.
JohnDenver
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2145
Joined: Sun 29 Aug 2004, 03:00:00

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby TheDude » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 23:09:08

Pixie wrote:If oil were to not peak, our numbers and consumption would eventually be curtailed by some form of pollution, which would permanently poison our habitat.


Like this:

Image

This is a crude poll. I see you tried to add at least a third option, oil-finder.

Oil peaking would be a good thing, as it's the only way to wake people up. If we are to sustain the experiment of society we need to curb growth and attendant energy demands/resource exploitation. Don't think that makes me a sociopath as you are semi-intimating.
Cogito, ergo non satis bibivi
And let me tell you something: I dig your work.
User avatar
TheDude
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 4896
Joined: Thu 06 Apr 2006, 03:00:00
Location: 3 miles NW of Champoeg, Republic of Cascadia

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Twilight » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 23:17:47

The poll shows a slim majority of respondents want world oil production to peak. Oil-Finder claims this desire would make them difficult to convince otherwise. Perhaps so. This is a moot point however, as the facts point in their favour anyway. They might be stubborn, they might have an environmental agenda, but they backed the right horse. What is a man to do?
Twilight
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 3027
Joined: Fri 02 Mar 2007, 04:00:00

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Oil-Finder » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 23:18:38

thuja wrote:Oil-finder I am impressed you would stick around here as you will find few to no allies- so kudos for you for sticking it out. On the other hand- I think your logic leaves something to be desired. It goes something like this-

Those who want Peak Oil (for ecological reasons/Global Warming) lasck the rationality to even acknowledge new finds or the potential for greater oil exploitation because they are so locked into their belief that they are blind, in denial and locked into a semi-religious belief system around the peaking of fossil fuels.

I've had many debates on other internet forums with peak oilers who've responded exactly how I described. That's what I base my observation on. Yes, many of them behave exactly like that.

I would have to suggest the opposite- that anyone studying the issue with any degree of open-mindedness will soon see that it is evident that we have peaked or are very near the peaking of oil. This is not a desire led belief leading to blindness- it is self-evident and has been noted by...everybody (IEA, Oil companies, even CERA). You are completely alone. If on the other hand you ignore the reality of the situation then I would suggest that it is you in a state of semi-religious denial. Sorry...

So do some of us want the peak of oil and that colors our thinking? No we acknowledge the peaking and then see the possible advantages...

Well your last paragraph is a sort-of middle ground (which, again, was an option the forum software cut off when I created the poll).

No I am not completely alone, there are plenty of non-peak oilers out there. If you want to know the details of my views, I am somewhere between a "gradual transformationist" and a "cornucopian." But that's off-topic.
User avatar
Oil-Finder
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 630
Joined: Tue 11 Dec 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Seattle

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby thuja » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 23:43:46

Oil-Finder wrote:
No I am not completely alone, there are plenty of non-peak oilers out there. If you want to know the details of my views, I am somewhere between a "gradual transformationist" and a "cornucopian." But that's off-topic.


I really don't know what a non-peak oiler looks like unless it is someone who believes in abiotic oil and the ever replenishing planetary creamy nugget of oil theory- which I really really hope you don't believe...

Otherwise everyone "believes" in Peak Oil- everyone- the only issue is when -and even that is just a matter of a couple decades and getting less by the day.

So again- the question "Do you want it to occur" is like asking "Do you want objects to fall to Earth?" It is not about want or not want- it is simply acknowledging reality.

But you point to a more interesting question..."Are you happy about the imminent decline in oil production?" That shows that it is a given that it is happening but how do you personally react to it.

Like I said- it is complex for me...sadness at the potential collapse of society and untold misery and death- versus the chance for sustaining the carrying capacity of the Earth down the road...
User avatar
thuja
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2202
Joined: Sat 15 Oct 2005, 03:00:00
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Peak oil: Do you want it to occur?

Unread postby Oil-Finder » Fri 28 Dec 2007, 23:50:09

^
When I say "non-peak oiler" I mean someone who doesn't think oil production will peak any time in the foreseeable future. Or if it does, it will peak because a better alternative has been found.

Who knows - maybe they'll perfect a viable electric car someday and develop fusion power, and therefore oil production will decline because oil demand will decline. A "non-peak oiler" might hold a view like that. And/or perhaps they believe there is still another several trillion barrels of recoverable oil left in the ground, and therefore we don't have to worry about oil production peaking for a very, very long time.
User avatar
Oil-Finder
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 630
Joined: Tue 11 Dec 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Seattle

PreviousNext

Return to Peak Oil Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 36 guests