MonteQuest wrote:AdamB wrote:The US obviously wasn't in the terminal decline you claimed it was. Would you care to revise your statement, in lieu of not remembering what you said very well?
In that thread I did say the US was in terminal decline.
Obviously. After having claimed previously that you had never claimed a peak occurring before.
MonteQuest wrote: At the time
everyone thought it was, 35 years after the peak. Hardly a criticism you can lay on anybody.
You are trolling.
Can't lay it on Mr Reserve. Can't lay it on Rockman. Can lay it on those who said what you said. Just because YOU drank the Koolaid doesn't mean you get to pretend everyone was as gullible. Lynch knew better. Yergin knew better. The EIA knew better.
So no, you don't get to pretend that everyone fell for the scary tales that you want to recycle and pretend are going to happen yet again, when oil does get around to peaking. Unless it already has, as Jeff Brown asserts.
MonteQuest wrote:But we are talking about world oil peaking, not just the US. In the 80's, new Alaskan oil interrupted the US terminal decline for a few years. Same short-term blip will happen with shale oil, I would imagine. Even before low prices arrived, the EIA was predicting shale oil would peak in 2020. It's more than likely, it has peaked now.
I have never called world peakoil or ever predicted a date.
Backpedaling some more is perfectly fine.
How many years of professional experience as an ecologist? You did say this is what your occupation was, right? To get that kind of degree, you HAD to have taken some math, right? Logic? Stats? SOMETHING quantitative?
MonteQuest wrote:Peak oil will only be seen in the rearview mirror.
And after Thanksgiving Day, 2005 (which includes most of the posts I'm quoting from this thread), it was in the rearview mirror. People far more qualified than even Mr Brown said so. At that time, you certainly weren't soft selling your ideas on those poor canaries, and you certainly weren't calling foul like those who didn't buy what you were selling.
Plant Thu 27 Jul 2023 "Personally I think the IEA is exactly right when they predict peak oil in the 2020s, especially because it matches my own predictions."
Plant Wed 11 Apr 2007 "I think Deffeyes might have nailed it, and we are just past the overall peak in oil production. (Thanksgiving 2005)"