Donate Bitcoin

Donate Paypal


PeakOil is You

PeakOil is You

Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Discussions of conventional and alternative energy production technologies.

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby KaiserJeep » Sun 24 Apr 2016, 22:23:35

onlooker wrote:Human instincts are powerful of that I agree with you. Evolution is slow, that I also agree. What I think you may not understand it that unlike animals who are subservient to our instincts, we are not. We can think and rationalize and thus override our instincts. We can chose higher virtues over primitive urges. It is true that is has not been common in our history but they're are examples. The American Indians had a culture which integrated family values with tribal values. The Spartans of Ancient Greece, had a warrior like culture that had a strong sense of responsibility and self-sacrifice. The point being that Culture is what allows for humans to unite in specific ways that may or may not emphasize selfish primitive urges. Or that may emphasize cooperation over competition. Culture can encapsulate a family and also a country. Thus you have Capitalism as a mode of culture that encourages these primitive reactions and that is so pervasive now in the US. In other poorer countries you will see something different, you will see people helping others even non family members as witnessed by reactions to Natural disasters. So, the manner in which humans seek to organize and run their affairs to a large degree determines the group dynamic of that group of humans. I know you would probably disagree but I believe we are capable of transcending our primitive nature and evolving into beings with a more refined intellect and a more virtuous and benevolent nature towards each other and towards Nature.



Well, I would agree that some people are capable of overcoming instincts - about 1% of the population at large, and only after they have had a university level education and have bought into the planetary goals we have been talking about. But there will never be enough of these people to make a difference - educational standards are decaying, not improving.

Pragmatically, you might be right about what we should be doing, but there is simply no chance whatsoever that this will happen.
KaiserJeep 2.0, Neural Subnode 0010 0000 0001 0110 - 1001 0011 0011, Tertiary Adjunct to Unimatrix 0000 0000 0001

Resistance is Futile, YOU will be Assimilated.

Warning: Messages timestamped before April 1, 2016, 06:00 PST were posted by the unmodified human KaiserJeep 1.0
KaiserJeep
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 6094
Joined: Tue 06 Aug 2013, 17:16:32
Location: Wisconsin's Dreamland

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby ralfy » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 02:16:27

As shown in some of the real data presented in this article:

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre ... g-collapse

capitalism requires continuous growth. But that is not sustainable given limitations in resources and coupled with pollution. Given these, it is expected that at some point economic growth will stop, and with that the human population go into decline.
User avatar
ralfy
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 5571
Joined: Sat 28 Mar 2009, 11:36:38
Location: The Wasteland

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby Quinny » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 04:33:31

Simply repeating the myth that capitalism is the natural state of affairs in humans and extending it to primates does not prove it.

There are lot's of studies to the contrary.
Live, Love, Learn, Leave Legacy.....oh and have a Laugh while you're doing it!
User avatar
Quinny
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 3337
Joined: Thu 03 Jul 2008, 03:00:00

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby KaiserJeep » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 06:06:55

Quinny wrote:Simply repeating the myth that capitalism is the natural state of affairs in humans and extending it to primates does not prove it.

There are lot's of studies to the contrary.


All such studies are useless. There are centuries old Capitalist economies which have lasted through economic contractions such as the Great Depression and the great recession of 2008. There are at last count five active Socialist economies and over 70 places where they tried and failed.

Marxism/Socialism/Communism is clearly inferior. The USSR holds the record at somewhere around 60-70 years, but it failed and is now a Capitalist Oligarchy.

Simply repeating the myth that there are viable alternatives to Capitalism does not prove it.

Marxist Socialist countries are China, Cuba, Vietnam, North Korea and Laos. None are even a fraction as successful as the 100+ predominately Capitalist countries.
KaiserJeep 2.0, Neural Subnode 0010 0000 0001 0110 - 1001 0011 0011, Tertiary Adjunct to Unimatrix 0000 0000 0001

Resistance is Futile, YOU will be Assimilated.

Warning: Messages timestamped before April 1, 2016, 06:00 PST were posted by the unmodified human KaiserJeep 1.0
KaiserJeep
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 6094
Joined: Tue 06 Aug 2013, 17:16:32
Location: Wisconsin's Dreamland

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby radon1 » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 09:05:45

KaiserJeep wrote:
Nor does Capitalism require constant growth or constant market expansion.


Capitalism requires non-capitalist surroundings to absorb in order to operate, otherwise it falls into a deflationary depression. This effectively spells the end of capitalism.

Assertion that capitalism is inherently environmentally-friendly just because some (supposedly) capitalist picked up a (supposedly) environmentally-friendly practice because it is (supposedly) profitable is a strawman.
radon1
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2054
Joined: Thu 27 Jun 2013, 06:09:44

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby onlooker » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 09:10:52

radon1 wrote:
KaiserJeep wrote:
Nor does Capitalism require constant growth or constant market expansion.


Capitalism requires non-capitalist surroundings to absorb in order to operate, otherwise it falls into a deflationary depression. This effectively spells the end of capitalism.

Assertion that capitalism is inherently environmentally-friendly just because some (supposedly) capitalist picked up a (supposedly) environmentally-friendly practice because it is (supposedly) profitable is a strawman.

Great retort Radon. Capitalism tends to stagnate and eventually die without growth as in profit. Also, yes the environmental friendly aspect of it is bogus. The overriding need and even more desire for profit makes Capitalism play out exactly as it has, with no regards to the environment and an impetus to grow indefinitely.
"We are mortal beings doomed to die
User avatar
onlooker
Fission
Fission
 
Posts: 10957
Joined: Sun 10 Nov 2013, 13:49:04
Location: NY, USA

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby KaiserJeep » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 10:19:27

Silly twaddle. Capitalism hasn't "tended" to do anything. It has existed and provided for those that work, whether the economy grows, contracts, or stays steady state.

Then there are those pesky facts: There have been no successful long term Marxist, Socialist, Stalinist, or Communist economies - not any, ever.
KaiserJeep 2.0, Neural Subnode 0010 0000 0001 0110 - 1001 0011 0011, Tertiary Adjunct to Unimatrix 0000 0000 0001

Resistance is Futile, YOU will be Assimilated.

Warning: Messages timestamped before April 1, 2016, 06:00 PST were posted by the unmodified human KaiserJeep 1.0
KaiserJeep
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 6094
Joined: Tue 06 Aug 2013, 17:16:32
Location: Wisconsin's Dreamland

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby ROCKMAN » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 10:30:04

I’ve yet to see any national economy (capitalistic, Marxist, communist, etc.) choose to negatively impact its citizens financially to any significant degree by placing the environment above the expectations of it citizens. Lots of rhetoric and some tiny Band-Aids. But as the lady said in that Wendy’s commercial: “Where the beef?”. LOL. We can amuse ourselves here by talking theories all we won’t. But that isn’t going to change what we see going on around the world today. We can assign whatever tags we want to the structure of any financial system but it doesn’t change the dynamics behind it: the basic human desires.
User avatar
ROCKMAN
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 11397
Joined: Tue 27 May 2008, 03:00:00
Location: TEXAS

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby ralfy » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 12:31:15

As explained in other threads, the reason why capitalism requires and involves growth is obvious:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_accumulation
User avatar
ralfy
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 5571
Joined: Sat 28 Mar 2009, 11:36:38
Location: The Wasteland

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby ROCKMAN » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 12:36:18

ralfy - Between the combination of population growth and the desire of most to improve their lives is there any system that doesn't require growth?
User avatar
ROCKMAN
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 11397
Joined: Tue 27 May 2008, 03:00:00
Location: TEXAS

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby onlooker » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 12:39:03

Or another way of putting it is can humans learn to live without growth either population or in consumption etc. ?
"We are mortal beings doomed to die
User avatar
onlooker
Fission
Fission
 
Posts: 10957
Joined: Sun 10 Nov 2013, 13:49:04
Location: NY, USA

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby KaiserJeep » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 13:11:32

The answer would be a resounding NO. We are not talking about education, culture, environmental policies, economics, or government. We are talking about millions of years of primate behaviors, where one feels the most care for self and immediate family, less for the ape troop or extended family, and active hostility towards anybody outside of this local group.

Within the last year I visited my hometown in Southern Illinois. Still has a population of 15,xxx. Still has four elementary schools, two intermediate schools, and one high school. Still has four large manufacturing plants, has good, bad, and in-between neighborhoods, over a dozen large churches, and another dozen smaller churches. Still has slightly over 50% of the people I knew in school, most of whom have seldom if ever even gone outside this place.

These are ape behaviors, tribal territory, and extended family groups. Same as Lucy the Australopithecus afarensis in 3.2 Million years BC. There probably are some observable differences in behavior between Australopithecus afarensis and Homo Sapiens Sapiens, but the bulk of ape behaviors are the same - just as today among the remaining ape species.
Image
I really doubt that more than a few of these Southern Illinois folks have ever read Marx. Certainly it would make no difference if they had. These type of people, quietly satisfying ape instincts, are the majority of humans on Earth.
Image
In another 3.2 Million years, there will be observable differences between the new species of human and Homo Sapiens Sapiens, just as there certainly are between Australopithecus afarensis and ourselves. Again, most behaviors will be the same.
Image
That is the pace of evolutionary change. Argue, wring your hands, venerate Marx if you must - it makes no difference in human behavior, which has not changed one iota in recorded history.
KaiserJeep 2.0, Neural Subnode 0010 0000 0001 0110 - 1001 0011 0011, Tertiary Adjunct to Unimatrix 0000 0000 0001

Resistance is Futile, YOU will be Assimilated.

Warning: Messages timestamped before April 1, 2016, 06:00 PST were posted by the unmodified human KaiserJeep 1.0
KaiserJeep
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 6094
Joined: Tue 06 Aug 2013, 17:16:32
Location: Wisconsin's Dreamland

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby radon1 » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 14:39:01

ROCKMAN wrote:I’ve yet to see any national economy (capitalistic, Marxist, communist, etc.)


Growth is more an exception than a rule. Throughout the history, national economies have normally been in depression. The last two hundred years are an exception that may be coming to its end.
radon1
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2054
Joined: Thu 27 Jun 2013, 06:09:44

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby kublikhan » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 15:32:16

ROCKMAN wrote:I’ve yet to see any national economy (capitalistic, Marxist, communist, etc.) choose to negatively impact its citizens financially to any significant degree by placing the environment above the expectations of it citizens.
What about the native american nations that were here before us? They seem to have had a deep regard for nature and maintaining it's balance.

Every seed is awakened and so is all animal life. It is through this mysterious power that we too have our being and we therefore yield to our animal neighbours the same right as ourselves, to inhabit this land. - Sitting Bull

The environmental wisdom and spirituality of North American Indians is legendary. Animals were respected as equal in rights to humans. The Indians viewed the white man's attitude to nature as the polar opposite of the Indian. The white man seemed hell-bent on destroying not just the Indians, but the whole natural order, felling forests, clearing land, killing animals for sport.
North American Indians: the spirituality of nature

Balance in the environment
Like other native peoples, the Cherokees did not try to rule over nature but instead tried to keep their proper place within it. In order to respect and cooperate with all of nature, the natives found ways to conserve its parts. When Cherokees gathered medicinal plants in the forest, they harvested only every fourth one they found, leaving the other three to grow undisturbed for a future use.

All of these practices contributed to the balance of their world. The Cherokees believed that if the balance of nature was upset, everyone would have trouble. They feared a loss of balance could cause sickness, bad weather, failed crops, poor hunting, and many other problems. Humans were responsible for keeping the balance within themselves and between the animals, the plants, and other people.
Maintaining balance: The religious world of the Cherokees

onlooker wrote:Or another way of putting it is can humans learn to live without growth either population or in consumption etc. ?
If you go way back to the days before agriculture, human growth in population and consumption was barely a trickle. It took thousands of years for human numbers to double back then. You could even argue that the vast majority of human history was at levels of no or very low growth. The rapid growth in human numbers and consumption is a more recent phenomenon, relatively speaking.
The oil barrel is half-full.
User avatar
kublikhan
Master Prognosticator
Master Prognosticator
 
Posts: 5002
Joined: Tue 06 Nov 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Illinois

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby onlooker » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 15:44:49

If you go way back to the days before agriculture, human growth in population and consumption was barely a trickle. It took thousands of years for human numbers to double back then. You could even argue that the vast majority of human history was at levels of no or very low growth. The rapid growth in human numbers and consumption is a more recent phenomenon, relatively speaking.

Thanks Kublikhan for those insights. Yes our generation is so used to growth that we do not realize that past generations lived both voluntarily and forcefully within the limits of Nature. By forcefully I mean our nemesis has always been bacteria and viruses so adept at making us sick and killing us. As for your allusion to the American Indians, very good, I too have mentioned them as an example of a culture that lived a shared community type of existence and that lived in relative harmony with each other and Nature. Again, Capitalism does not serve the purpose of living in this sustainable and harmonious manner, in fact quite the opposite.
"We are mortal beings doomed to die
User avatar
onlooker
Fission
Fission
 
Posts: 10957
Joined: Sun 10 Nov 2013, 13:49:04
Location: NY, USA

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby ROCKMAN » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 16:51:39

K - You mean the same native Americans that committed their own form of genocide from time to time as well as taking slaves and killing to expand territories? That a nice romantic view you have of those folks but what about this hypothetical: what if Europeans hadn't taken over those lands and the native population grew to unsustainable levels? Same eventual situation that led Europeans to invade the north American continent perhaps. Of course being a hypothetical there's no provable answer. But reverse the rolls: what if native Americans with a booming population had invaded Mexico and Central America? Again one can only make up an unprovable answer. But whose to ay native Americans would not have followed a similar path given the opportunity.
User avatar
ROCKMAN
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 11397
Joined: Tue 27 May 2008, 03:00:00
Location: TEXAS

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby kublikhan » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 17:54:07

I was not trying to paint them as pacifists. I was speaking of their attitudes on environmental stewardship. To me, there appears to be a clear difference in how our cultures viewed nature. Our culture seeks to bend nature to our will. Dominate it, exploit it, etc. Where as the native american culture sought to live in balance and harmony with nature. Were their failures in pursuit of this ideal? Certainly. But there is still a sharp contrast in how they viewed nature and tried to live in balance with it. Ecologists today have to actually teach us that we are part of nature, not above it. All too often however this message falls on deaf ears. Our culture infused our heads with other ideas. Yet this message was already a core tenant of native american culture.

For many years, ecologists have been trying to get people to think of the world in ecological terms— that is, seeing the interconnectedness of the natural world and by doing it through purely empirical research. More specifically, to see humans not as rulers of the earth but as fellow citizens with all life forms and to see the biosphere as a continually conserved natural order of nutrients cycling through both living and non-living parts of the environment. This interconnectedness is evident in genome analysis, as every living organism shares vastly similar genes. All of this information would never have to be taught to a typical Native American, however. Their entire method of living is inherently ecological because, to them, everything in the natural world was interrelated and shared the same life. Their lifestyles as well as their religion only served to emphasize this relationship between man and his environment. Modern ecologists have only recently started to appreciate Native Americans’ ecological practices.

The Natives did, in fact, pay more attention to their environment much more than any other known culture of the time because nature, to them, stood for a representation of the sacred. “If we describe a Native American as a conservationist, we do not mean that he calculates sustainable yield into the distant future… but rather that he does not waste or ‘despoil, exhaust or extinguish,’ and [he] leaves the environment and resources like animal populations in a usable state for succeeding generations.”

Lastly, the most fundamental difference, generally speaking, between Native American and European cultures is the fact that the Natives viewed every form of life as having an intrinsic value, not simply instrumental.
Probing the Relationship Between Native Americans and Ecology
The oil barrel is half-full.
User avatar
kublikhan
Master Prognosticator
Master Prognosticator
 
Posts: 5002
Joined: Tue 06 Nov 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Illinois

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby onlooker » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 17:59:11

This is quite logical and simple to understand. In the past people had limited power over nature and were subject to its limitations and parameters. It is modern civilization which utilizing planet changing technology has sought to dominate and bend Nature to its will. Modern humans have risen above some of the limitations and parameters of Nature and that was another reason we seemed to detach from any type of subservience and deference to Nature.
"We are mortal beings doomed to die
User avatar
onlooker
Fission
Fission
 
Posts: 10957
Joined: Sun 10 Nov 2013, 13:49:04
Location: NY, USA

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby kublikhan » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 19:03:45

Well technology is part of it. But Christianity and our philosophers also seemed to have had a hand in shaping this view.

The profound influence of a Judeo-Christian tradition on the western perception of nature was noted early in the debate about the causes of environmental degradation. Lynn White argues "the present increasing disruption of the global environment is the product of a dynamic technology and science which […] cannot be understood historically apart from distinctive attitudes toward nature which are deeply grounded in Christian dogma" (White 1967). The Bible seems to indicate in various passages that nature was designed to meet human needs exclusively. The spirit is separated from nature and what matters is the individual relationship between God the creator and humans as his superior creatures. Unlike Animism, where nature itself is worshiped and praised, Christian belief segregates the sphere of sacredness from the natural environment, thus assigning it to the level of a supportive structure. The story of Creation is essentially a story of authorisation and legitimation. God transfers his unlimited authority over all the living creatures of the world to Man, making him the "Lord of nature".

The spread of Judeo-Christian culture into environments substantially different from its place of origin – the deserts and semi-arid zone of Palestine, for example – has also contributed to the dominant ideology of human-nature relations. As the simple and hostile environment of the JudeoChristian birthplace was abandoned for the more complex and resource-rich environment of northern Europe, without changing the basic perception of nature as an enemy to be defeated, the ideology of mastery over nature spread to regions where it could do substantial harm.

But despite the many religious justifications of human authority over the earth and its creatures, Man did not perceive himself as an absolute ruler, but as God’s loyal servant. As nature was God’s creation, it was deemed sacred, and thus protected against destruction to a certain degree. It was only after secularisation took hold in Europe following the Reformation, that this safety valve broke down and allowed for the full-scale application of the disastrous ideology of control (Leiss 1974: 34). The Renaissance freed the mindset of domination from the limitations of religious dogma, but it failed to provide for a new ethic capable of regulating the relation between humankind and nature in the absence of a religious justification for the "rape of the earth".

The work of Francis Bacon is an illuminating example of the embeddedness of scientific progress and the domination of nature in a religious context. "By casting his plea for scientific progress in a familiar religious mold, he managed to win wide acceptance for a novel conception of mastery over nature, and at the same time he unwittingly charted a course for later generations which led to the gradual secularisation of this idea" (Leiss 1974: 53). It was Bacon's achievement in formulating the concept of mastery over nature as a new scientific and practical enterprise (Russell 1961: 527). René Descartes’ contribution to the development of modern science contains the deterministic segregation of mind and matter and the method of reductionism that led to a purely mechanistic worldview. This approach to scientific enquiry "inevitably led to a fragmented view of the world – to a focus on the individual parts of a system rather than on the organic whole, on studying the way in which the constituent elements operated separately rather than the ways in which they interacted" (Ponting 1991: 147). This resulted in the perception of humans and nature as governed strictly by the laws of physics, and thus it favoured the exploitation of the one by the other. It was Isaac Newton at the end of this essential phase of scientific development who transcended all these efforts by formulating an abstract and geometrised universe that was governed by the one fundamental principle of gravitation (Braudel 1993: 368). This substantial achievement enabled future generations of scientists to systemise the forces of nature into an abstract set of basic principles and rules, which resulted in a radical alienation of western civilisation from the notion of nature as a complex and mystical entity.
Conquest, Domination and Control: Europe’s Mastery of Nature in Historic Perspective

The heavens are Yours, the earth also is Yours; The world and all it contains, You have founded them.
Psalm 89:11

Then God said, "Let us make mankind in our image, to be like us. Let them be masters over the fish in the ocean, the birds that fly, the livestock, everything that crawls on the earth, and over the earth itself!"
genesis 1-26
The oil barrel is half-full.
User avatar
kublikhan
Master Prognosticator
Master Prognosticator
 
Posts: 5002
Joined: Tue 06 Nov 2007, 04:00:00
Location: Illinois

Re: Earth Day Shocker! Capitalism Saves the Planet!

Unread postby Shaved Monkey » Mon 25 Apr 2016, 19:20:41

onlooker wrote:Or another way of putting it is can humans learn to live without growth either population or in consumption etc. ?

Given enough time they will have no choice.
Ready to turn Zombies into WWOOFers
User avatar
Shaved Monkey
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 2486
Joined: Wed 30 Mar 2011, 01:43:28

PreviousNext

Return to Energy Technology

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 40 guests

cron